3D Printing Functional Parts with Selective Laser Sintering
Sintering is the process of applying heat and/or pressure to fuse bits of metal, ceramic, and other materials into a solid mass. It’s nothing new. Nature has been fusing sedimentary minerals into slate and quartzite for eons, and humans began using similar methods to make bricks and porcelain millennia ago. Today, sintering is used to produce everything from gears and connecting rods to sprockets and bearings. It’s also used to 3D print parts.
Selective laser sintering (SLS) is a close cousin to direct metal laser sintering (DMLS), but builds parts made of plastic rather than metal. SLS uses a computer-controlled CO2 laser versus an ND: YAG fiber laser for DMLS, but both “draw” slices of a CAD model in a bed of material, fusing micron-sized particles of material one layer at a time.
SLS needs none of the support structures typical with DMLS, however, and unlike stereolithography (SL)—the third laser-based additive manufacturing (AM) process available at Proto Labs—SLS creates fully functional parts using engineering-grade nylon, and is essentially the only AM technology able to create living hinges and snap-fit assemblies. (These features can be produced with SL, however, they will be much more fragile and not have the life expectancy of those produced with SLS). This makes it an excellent way to prototype injection-molded products, and can even be used as a low-volume alternative to molding in some cases.
Rooted in Nylon
As with any additive process, it’s important to understand the many design considerations applicable to SLS. One of these is the material. Despite their wide-ranging uses, all SLS parts are currently limited to nylon materials—the same thermoplastics used in fasteners, flak jackets, frying pans, and thousands of other everyday items. Proto Labs offers four grades of these versatile polymers:
- PA 850 Black: Similar to an unfilled Nylon 11, this tough bioplastic is an excellent choice for parts requiring a living hinge—the lid on a pill container, for example—and offers one of the highest elongation break thresholds in the nylon family. It’s black in color, produces a smooth surface finish and good part detail, and due to its superb chemical resistance and low water absorption, is ideal for products such as fuel lines, catheters, tennis shoes, and electrical connectors.
- PA 650 White: Similar to unfilled Nylon 12, PA 650 is both stiff and tough, and is used extensively in air ducts, sporting goods, and similar products. It presents a clean, white finish, but with a slightly rougher surface texture than other nylons. It offers high impact and temperature resistance, is very durable and remains stable under a range of environmental conditions. Nylon 12 also has a low coefficient of friction, making it suitable for many types of gears and bearings.
- PA 620-MF: A variant of Nylon 12, this material contains 25 percent mineral fiber, and is used for products requiring high structural strength and load-bearing properties. Like most nylons, it offers excellent stiffness at elevated temperatures, which is one reason why MF-filled nylon is a favorite among the aerospace and motorsports industries, and any AM applications needing an AM material that is strong and durable. It also has directional mechanical properties—the fibers will align in the X direction making it the strongest along that plane.
- PA 615-GS: This 50-percent glass-filled "flavor" of Nylon 12 is known for dimensional stability and resistance to high temperatures. It’s especially good for accurate, detailed parts with complex geometries, and outperforms unfilled nylon in demanding applications. However, the glass fill can be abrasive to mating surfaces, something that should be considered when designing parts with this rugged material. Both 615 and 620-MF will be much less flexible and 615-GS will be much heavier due to the glass content. It’s also important to note that 620-MF has a much better strength-to-weight ratio than 615-GS.
Managing the Build
These four types of nylon materials cover many different applications. Despite this, roughly 95 percent of the SLS material consumed at Proto Labs is PA 850 (Nylon 11) or PA 650 (Nylon 12), although the mineral- and glass-filled variants are gaining momentum. There’s far more to effective part design than material selection, however, and controlling the in-build curl and post-build warping common with AM is paramount to good part quality.
Much of this control falls to Proto Labs. To keep parts straight and true, our technicians will often tip parts slightly in the build chamber. If you’re designing a case for a handheld video game, for example, a compound incline of 10 to 15 degrees in the X and Y axes during the build is probably all that’s needed to keep the walls square and the box lid fitting smoothly. It’s important to point out that some “stair stepping” may occur as a result of this technique, so it’s important to identify cosmetic surfaces when submitting your design to Proto Labs for quoting and analysis.
It’s Never Too Early to Improve Moldability
Many of the rules applied in injection molding also apply to SLS, making it a solid choice for parts that will eventually be molded. The use of hole bosses and support struts, and avoiding thick cross-sections are good practices for either manufacturing process. Additional design considerations include:
- adding corner radii where walls meet to reduce stress
- uniform wall thickness—between 0.060 in. and 0.150 in. is recommended to reduce in-build curl and potential for warping
- integrating ribs to reduce warping
Where injection-molded parts can contain overmolded metal bushings or threaded inserts, SLS parts achieve comparable functionality via heat-stake inserts—in our handheld game example, threaded inserts can be heat-staked as a secondary process at each corner of the housing for strong assembly purposes.
Look and Feel
The surface finish produced by SLS is a bit rougher than other AM technologies—anywhere from 100-250 RMS—but it still works reasonably well for most functional prototypes. Proto Labs also bead blasts the majority of customers’ parts to remove loose powder and create a smooth matte finish. Very fine text is another consideration—since the minimum feature size with SLS is 0.030 in., very small fonts tend to get jammed with powder, making letters and numbers less legible. Moving to inset text provides better results, but is still limited to features no smaller than approximately 0.020 in. Lastly, SLS is slightly less accurate than competing laser sintering processes—where DMLS has expected tolerances of ±0.003 in. plus an additional 0.001 in./in. on metal parts, ±0.003 in. plus ±0.001 in./in. is typically achievable with SLS. On well-designed parts.
The upside here is that SLS has a build frame of 19 in. by 19 in. by 22 in. (482mm by 482mm by 558mm), far larger than its metal-making sidekick. And because there are no support structures involved, the entire powder bed can be utilized, making it easy to nest multiple parts into a single build. This makes SLS a solid alternative to machined plastic, a logical stepping-stone to injection molding, and an excellent way to produce functional nylon parts in higher volumes than is usually associated with AM.